MAGIC-f Gel Dosimeter Reading: A Comparison between an In-House Optical CT and MRI Imaging

Document Type : Original Paper


Department of Medical Physics and Biomedical Engineering, School of Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran


Introduction: According to new developments in radiation therapy techniques, accurate dose verification in three dimensions has become more critical. Polymer gel dosimeters (PGDs) are valuable tools to be used for this purpose. Nowadays, various imaging modalities are employed to read out the gels. This study was aimed to investigate the measured dose distribution recorded in MAGIC-f PGD with optical computed tomography (OCT) by comparison with MRI.
Material and Methods: We developed an in-house charge-coupled device (CCD) based cone-beam OCT scanner. A phantom of MAGIC-f PGD was used to measure a four-field box dose distribution. MRI and OCT scanners were performed for gel readouts. Both measurement results were compared by gamma index analysis with various acceptance criteria. The temporal stability of the gel was also evaluated with the OCT readout system.
Results: The percentage of isodose lines from two measured datasets agreed well together. The pass rates were 99.02%, 96.8%, and 89.8% with 5%/5mm, 4%/4mm, and 3%/3mm criteria, respectively, at the phantom's central axial slice.
Conclusion: The results indicate that the performance of this OCT system is almost the same with acceptable discrepancies to the MRI as accepted standard readout modality, and it can be used for three-dimensional dose verifications.


Main Subjects

  1. Schreiner LJ. Fundamentals of 3D dosimetry. InJournal of Physics: Conference Series 2019 Aug 1 (Vol. 1305, No. 1, p. 012022). IOP Publishing.
  2. Haraldsson P, Karlsson A, Wieslander E, Gustavsson H, Bäck SÅ. Dose response evaluation of a low-density normoxic polymer gel dosimeter using MRI. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2006 Feb 1;51(4):919.
  3. Novotný Jr J, Spěváček V, Dvořák P, Novotný J, Čechák T. Three-dimensional polymer gel dosimetry: basic physical properties of the dosimeter. Radiation Physics and Chemistry. 2001 Jun 1;61(3-6):255-8.
  4. Basfar AA, Moftah B, Rabaeh KA, Almousa AA. Novel composition of polymer gel dosimeters based on N-(Hydroxymethyl) acrylamide for radiation therapy. Radiation Physics and Chemistry. 2015 Jul 1;112:117-20.
  5. Turonok OC, Diachenko O, Alokhina MY, Bezshyyko O, Golinka-Bezshyyko L, Kadenko I, et al. Three-dimensional Polymer Dosimetry. WDS'13 Proceedings of Contributed Papers, Part III, 2013.58–
  6. Maryanski MJ, Audet C, Gore JC. Effects of crosslinking and temperature on the dose response of a BANG polymer gel dosimeter. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 1997 Feb;42(2):303.
  7. De Deene Y. Review of quantitative MRI principles for gel dosimetry. InJournal of Physics: Conference Series 2009 May 1 (Vol. 164, No. 1, p. 012033). IOP Publishing.
  8. Van Esch A, Clermont C, Devillers M, Iori M, Huyskens DP. On‐line quality assurance of rotational radiotherapy treatment delivery by means of a 2D ion chamber array and the Octavius phantom. Medical physics. 2007 Oct;34(10):3825-37.
  9. Nilsson G. SU‐FF‐T‐135: Delta4—A New IMRT QA Device. Medical Physics. 2007 Jun;34(6Part9):2432.
  10. Nilsson J, Hauer AK, Bäck A. IMRT patient-specific QA using the Delta4 dosimetry system and evaluation based on ICRU 83 recommendations. InJournal of Physics: Conference Series 2013 Jun 26 (Vol. 444, No. 1, p. 012048). IOP Publishing.
  11. Létourneau D, Publicover J, Kozelka J, Moseley DJ, Jaffray DA. Novel dosimetric phantom for quality assurance of volumetric modulated arc therapy. Medical physics. 2009 May;36(5):1813-21.
  12. Yan G, Lu B, Kozelka J, Liu C, Li JG. Calibration of a novel four‐dimensional diode array. Medical physics. 2010 Jan;37(1):108-15.
  13. Pavord D. SU‐GG‐T‐210: A Comparison of Dosimetry Devices. Medical Physics. 2008 Jun;35(6Part12):2773-4.
  14. Penn ST, Xue T. SU‐GG‐T‐170: Using a 3D Diode Array System to Perform Routine IMRT Machine QA. Medical Physics. 2008 Jun;35(6Part11):2765-.
  15. Hayati H, Mesbahi A. Impact of photon spectra on the sensitivity of polymer gel dosimetry by X-ray computed tomography. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2019;16(1):48-55.
  16. Gore JC, Kang YS. Measurement of radiation dose distributions by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) imaging. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 1984 Oct;29(10):1189.
  17. Adamovics J, Maryanski M. New 3D radiochromic solid polymer dosimeter from leuco dyes and a transparent polymeric matrix. Medical Physics. 2003 Jun;30(6).
  18. Mostaar A, Hashemi B, Zahmatkesh MH, Aghamiri SM, Mahdavi SR. A basic dosimetric study of PRESAGE: the effect of different amounts of fabricating components on the sensitivity and stability of the dosimeter. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2010 Jan 14;55(3):903.
  19. Mostaar A, Hashemi B, Zahmatkesh MH, Aghamiri SM, Mahdavi SR. Development and characterization of a novel PRESAGE formulation for radiotherapy applications. Applied Radiation and Isotopes. 2011 Oct 1;69(10):1540-5.
  20. Baldock C, Burford RP, Billingham NC, Cohen D, Keevil SF. Polymer gel composition in magnetic resonance imaging dosimetry. Med. Phys. 1996;23:1070.
  21. Maryanski MJ, Eastman P, Holcombe SD, Avison RG, Zhang Y, Gore JC. 122 Three dimensional visualization and measurement of conformal dose distributions using magnetic resonance imaging of bang polymer gel dosimeters. International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics. 1995(32):202.
  22. Hilts M, Audet C, Duzenli C, Jirasek A. Polymer gel dosimetry using x-ray computed tomography: a feasibility study4. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2000 Sep 1;45(9):2559.
  23. Gore JC, Ranade M, Maryanski MJ, Schulz RJ. Radiation dose distributions in three dimensions from tomographic optical density scanning of polymer gels: I. Development of an optical scanner. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 1996 Dec;41(12):2695.
  24. Mather ML, Whittaker AK, Baldock C. Ultrasound evaluation of polymer gel dosimeters. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2002 Apr 19;47(9):1449.
  25. Mather ML, Charles PH, Baldock C. Measurement of ultrasonic attenuation coefficient in polymer gel dosimeters. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2003 Sep 30;48(20):N269.
  26. Baldock C, Rintoul L, Keevil SF, Pope JM, George GA. Fourier transform Raman spectroscopy of polyacrylamide gels (PAGs) for radiation dosimetry. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 1998 Dec;43(12):3617.
  27. Mesbahi A, Zakariaee SS. Optical characterization of NIPAM and PAGAT polymer gels for radiation dosimetry. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2014;11(3-4):188-94.
  28. Oldham M, editor. Optical-CT scanning of polymer gels. Third international conference of radiotherapy gel dosimetry; 2004 Sep 13-16: Ghent University, Gent, Belgium. J Phys: Conf Ser; IOP publishing; 2004.p.122-135
  29. Wolodzko JG, Marsden C, Appleby A. CCD imaging for optical tomography of gel radiation dosimeters. Medical Physics. 1999 Nov;26(11):2508-13.
  30. Doran SJ, Krstajić N. The history and principles of optical computed tomography for scanning 3-D radiation dosimeters. InJournal of Physics: Conference Series 2006 Dec 1 (Vol. 56, No. 1, p. 005). IOP Publishing.
  31. Oldham M, Siewerdsen JH, Shetty A, Jaffray DA. High resolution gel‐dosimetry by optical‐CT and MR scanning. Medical physics. 2001 Jul;28(7):1436-45.
  32. Fernandes JP, Pastorello BF, de Araújo DB, Baffa O. Formaldehyde increases MAGIC gel dosimeter melting point and sensitivity. InJournal of Physics: Conference Series 2009 May 1 (Vol. 164, No. 1, p. 012004). IOP Publishing.
  33. Shiri M, Mostaar A, Mansouri Z, Sadat-Shahabi SM. Designing and developing an in-house CCD based optical CT scanner for gel dosimetry. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2018 Dec 1;15(Special Issue-12th. Iranian Congress of Medical Physics):6-.
  34. Baldock C, De Deene Y, Doran S, Ibbott G, Jirasek A, Lepage M, et al. Polymer gel dosimetry. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2010 Feb 11;55(5):R1.35.
  35. Low DA, Harms WB, Mutic S, Purdy JA. A technique for the quantitative evaluation of dose distributions. Medical physics. 1998 May;25(5):656-61.
  36. Low DA, Dempsey JF. Evaluation of the gamma dose distribution comparison method. Medical physics. 2003 Sep;30(9):2455-64.
  37. Awad SI, Moftah B, Basfer A, Almousa AA, Al Kafi MA, Eyadeh MM, Rabaeh KA. 3-D quality assurance in CyberKnife radiotherapy using a novel N-(3-methoxypropyl) acrylamide polymer gel dosimeter and optical CT. Radiation Physics and Chemistry. 2019 Aug 1;161:34-41.
  38. Pavoni JF, Pike TL, Snow J, DeWerd L, Baffa O. Tomotherapy dose distribution verification using MAGIC‐f polymer gel dosimetry. Medical physics. 2012 May;39(5):2877-84.
  39. Yao CH, Hsu WT, Lee JJ, Hsu SM, Ma PY, Hsieh BT, Chang YJ. A characteristic study on NIPAM gel dosimetry using optical-CT scanner. Journal of Medical and Biological Engineering. 2014 Aug 1;34(4):327-32.
  40. Oldham M, Gluckman G, Kim L, editors. 3D verification of a prostate IMRT treatment by polymer gel-dosimetry and optical-CT scanning. Third international conference on radiotherapy gel dosimetry;2004 Sep 13-16: Ghent University, Gent, Belgium. J Phys: Conf Ser; IOP Publishing: 2004.p.293.
  41. Chang Y, Lin J, Hsieh B, Chen C, editors. A study on the reproducibility and spatial uniformity of N-isopropylacrylamide polymer gel dosimetry using a commercial 10X fast optical-computed tomography scanner.7th international conference on 3d radiation dosimetry (IC3DDose); 2012 Dec 4-8: Sydney, Australia. J Phys: Conf Ser; IOP Publishing: 2013.p.012067
  42. Mahdavi M, Hosseinnezhad M, Mahdavi SR. Development of an Advanced Optical Coherence Tomography System for Radiation Dosimetry. Iran. J. Med. Phys. 2018 Oct 1;15(4):243-50.
  43. Pavoni JF, Baffa O. An evaluation of dosimetric characteristics of MAGIC gel modified by adding formaldehyde (MAGIC-f). Radiation measurements. 2012 Nov 1;47(11-12):1074-82.
Volume 18, Issue 6
November and December 2021
Pages 430-437
  • Receive Date: 01 November 2020
  • Revise Date: 04 February 2021
  • Accept Date: 27 February 2021