Dosimetric Comparison of Fractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy Plans With And Without Flattening Filter Beams of 6 MV And 10 MV Beams

Document Type : Original Paper

Authors

1 Department of Physics, Research Scholar, Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore, India

2 Department of Physics, School of Sciences, Arts, Media and Mangement, Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore-641 114 Tamilnadu India

3 Radiation Oncology Department, Senior Consultant, Aster Mims Hospital, Calicut, India

4 Chief Medical Physicist Department of Radiation Oncology Fortis Hospital, Sector 62, Phase 8, SAS Nagar, Mohali-160062, Punjab India

Abstract

Introduction: It is necessary to understand the importance of different energies in Fractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy (FSRT) plans for better outcome. The study objective is to compare FSRT plans with Flattening Filter (FF) and Flattening Filter Free (FFF) beams.
Material and Methods: Twelve patients with primary Brain Metastasis (BM), were selected and given 25 Gy in five fractions for which 6FF beams were angled in double arc. The Planning Target Volume (PTV) and Organs at Risk (OARs) were assessed using dosimetric indices after each plan was replanned with 6 FFF, 10 FF, and 10 FFF energies. Treatment time (TT) and Monitor Units (MUs) were also compared. Additionally, we compared portal dosimetry for dose agreement across all plans using the gamma analysis criterion.
Results: PTV parameters of created plans showed better values when compared to 6 FF plans, where the most significant is with FFF plans which include D98%, D80%, D2%, D50% and Dose Gradient Index values of 6FFF plans. Among OARs, the most significant is the V10 value of (Brain-PTV) as (46.77±43.9) and maximum dose values of optic chiasm, brainstem, and left lens in 6FFF plans. Among technical parameters, the 6FFF plan showed significant TT value of (3.06±1.0) with p-value 4.13E-05. Better gamma analysis passing rates were achieved with FFF beams.
Conclusion: Linear accelerator-based FSRT delivery of BM using 6 FFF beam results in better dosimetric indices, OAR sparing, fastest treatment delivery, and energy conservation with reduced peripheral and out-of-field dose for higher treatment modalities like Rapid arc.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Aoyama H. Radiation therapy for brain metastases in breast cancer patients. Breast Cancer. 2011 Oct;18(4):244-51.
  2. Nieder C, Grosu AL, Gaspar LE. Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for brain metastases: a systematic review. Radiation Oncology. 2014 Dec;9(1):1-9.
  3. Rades D, Hornung D, Blanck O, Martens K, Khoa MT, Trang NT, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for newly diagnosed brain metastases. Strahlentherapie und Onkologie. 2014 Sep;190(9):786-91.
  4. Lin X, DeAngelis LM. Treatment of brain metastases. Journal of clinical oncology. 2015 Oct 10;33(30):3475.
  5. Yamamoto M, Serizawa T, Shuto T, Akabane A, Higuchi Y, Kawagishi J, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with multiple brain metastases (JLGK0901): a multi-institutional prospective observational study. The Lancet Oncology. 2014 Apr 1;15(4):387-95.
  6. MADESWARAN S. The dosimetric comparison of different SBRT techniques for treatment of liver cancer using flattened and flattening filter-free beam. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2022 May 15.
  7. Stieler F, Fleckenstein J, Simeonova A, Wenz F, Lohr F. Intensity modulated radiosurgery of brain metastases with flattening filter-free beams. Radiotherapy and oncology. 2013 Dec 1;109(3):448-51.
  8. Saroj D, Yadav S, Ghosh G, Shukla S, Gupta G, Choudhary S. Dosimetric Comparison between 6MV Flattened Filter and Flattening Filter Free Photon Beams in the Treatment of Glioblastoma with IMRT Technique: A Treatment Planning Study. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2020;17(3):188-96.
  9. Hoogeman MS, Nuyttens JJ, Levendag PC, Heijmen BJ. Time dependence of intrafraction patient motion assessed by repeat stereoscopic imaging. International Journal of Radiation Oncology* Biology* Physics. 2008 Feb 1;70(2):609-18.
  10. Akpati H, Kim C, Kim B, Park T, Meek A. Unified dosimetry index (UDI): a figure of merit for ranking treatment plans. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics. 2008 Jun;9(3):99-108.
  11. Uysal B, Beyzadeoğlu M, Sager Ö, Dinçoğlan F, Demiral S, Gamsiz H, et al. Dosimetric evaluation of intensity modulated radiotherapy and 4-field 3-D conformal radiotherapy in prostate cancer treatment. Balkan medical journal. 2013 Mar 1;2013(1):54-7.
  12. Zhuang M, Zhang T, Chen Z, Lin Z, Li D, Peng X, et al. Volumetric modulation arc radiotherapy with flattening filter-free beams compared with conventional beams for nasopharyngeal carcinoma: a feasibility study. Chinese journal of cancer. 2013 Jul;32(7):397.
  13. Kumar SA, Musthafa MM, Suja CA, Resmi KB, Jose L, Muttath G, et al. Dosimetric comparison of FF and FFF beams in VMAT treatment plans of head and neck cancers. Onkologia i Radioterapia. 2021 Jul 19;15(7):1-5.
  14. Kocher M, Wittig A, Piroth MD, Treuer H, Seegenschmiedt H, Ruge M, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for treatment of brain metastases. Strahlentherapie und Onkologie. 2014 Jun;190(6):521-32.
  15. Croker J, Chua B, Bernard A, Allon M, Foote M. Treatment of brain oligometastases with hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy utilising volumetric modulated arc therapy. Clinical & experimental metastasis. 2016 Feb;33(2):125-32.
  16. Alongi F, Fiorentino A, Mancosu P, Navarria P, Giaj Levra N, Mazzola R, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for intracranial metastases: linac-based and gamma-dedicated unit approach. Expert Review of Anticancer Therapy. 2016 Jul 2;16(7):731-40.
  17. Zhuang M, Zhang T, Chen Z, Lin Z, Li D, Peng X, et al. Advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma radiotherapy with volumetric modulated arcs and the potential role of flattening filter-free beams. Radiation Oncology. 2013 Dec;8(1):1-9.
  18. Stieler F, Fleckenstein J, Simeonova A, Wenz F, Lohr F. Intensity modulated radiosurgery of brain metastases with flattening filter-free beams. Radiotherapy and oncology. 2013 Dec 1;109(3):448-51.
  19. Rieber J, Tonndorf-Martini E, Schramm O, Rhein B, Stefanowicz S, Kappes J, et al. Radiosurgery with flattening-filter-free techniques in the treatment of brain metastases. Strahlentherapie und Onkologie. 2016 Nov;192(11):789-96.
  20. Kry SF, Vassiliev ON, Mohan R. Out-of-field photon dose following removal of the flattening filter from a medical accelerator. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2010 Mar 19;55(8):2155.
  21. Lechner W, Kragl G, Georg D. Evaluation of treatment plan quality of IMRT and VMAT with and without flattening filter using Pareto optimal fronts. Radiotherapy and Oncology. 2013 Dec 1;109(3):437-41.
  22. Thomas EM, Popple RA, Prendergast BM, Clark GM, Dobelbower MC, Fiveash JB. Effects of flattening filter‐free and volumetric‐modulated arc therapy delivery on treatment efficiency. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics. 2013 Nov;14(6):155-66.
  23. Kragl G, Baier F, Lutz S, Albrich D, Dalaryd M, Kroupa B, et al. Flattening filter free beams in SBRT and IMRT: dosimetric assessment of peripheral doses. Zeitschrift für medizinische Physik. 2011 May 1;21(2):91-101.
  24. Titt U, Vassiliev ON, Pönisch F, Dong L, Liu H, Mohan R. A flattening filter free photon treatment concept evaluation with Monte Carlo. Medical physics. 2006 Jun;33(6Part1):1595-602.
  25. Hartmann GH, Schlegel W, Sturm V, Kober B, Pastyr O, Lorenz WJ. Cerebral radiation surgery using moving field irradiation at a linear accelerator facility. International Journal of Radiation Oncology* Biology* Physics. 1985 Jun 1;11(6):1185-92.
  26. Zwahlen DR, Lang S, Hrbacek J, Glanzmann C, Kloeck S, Najafi Y, et al. The use of photon beams of a flattening filter-free linear accelerator for hypofractionated volumetric modulated arc therapy in localized prostate cancer. International Journal of Radiation Oncology* Biology* Physics. 2012 Aug 1;83(5):1655-60.
  27. Diallo I, Haddy N, Adjadj E, Samand A, Quiniou E, Chavaudra J, et al. Frequency distribution of second solid cancer locations in relation to the irradiated volume among 115 patients treated for childhood cancer. International Journal of Radiation Oncology* Biology* Physics. 2009 Jul 1;74(3):876-83.
  28. Kry SF, Vassiliev ON, Mohan R. Out-of-field photon dose following removal of the flattening filter from a medical accelerator. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2010 Mar 19;55(8):2155.
  29. Suresh T, Madeswaran S. Impact of 6 MV & 10 MV Flattened and Flattening Filter Free Beams in Whole Brain Radiotherapy: A Treatment Planning Study. Iranian Journal of Medical Physics. 2021;18(3):218-25.
  30. Xu LM, Kang ML, Jiang B, Liu QF, Li YX. A study of the dosimetric characteristics between different fixed-field IMRT and VMAT in early-stage primary mediastinal B-cell lymphoma. Medical Dosimetry. 2018 Mar 1;43(1):91-9.
  31. Vassiliev ON, Titt U, Pönisch F, Kry SF, Mohan R, Gillin MT. Dosimetric properties of photon beams from a flattening filter free clinical accelerator. Physics in Medicine & Biology. 2006 Mar 22;51(7):1907.
  32. Lohse I, Lang S, Hrbacek J, Scheidegger S, Bodis S, Macedo NS, et al. Effect of high dose per pulse flattening filter-free beams on cancer cell survival. Radiotherapy and Oncology. 2011 Oct 1;101(1):226-32.
  33. Montgomery L, Evans M, Liang L, Maglieri R, Kildea J. The effect of the flattening filter on photoneutron production at 10 MV in the Varian TrueBeam linear accelerator. Medical physics. 2018 Oct;45(10):4711-9.
  34. Kim HS, Lee JK. Assessment and measurement of the photoneutron field produced in the Varian medical linear accelerator. Journal of nuclear science and technology. 2007 Jan 1;44(1):95-101.
  35. Hudson A. Use of bubble detectors to characterize neutron dose distribution in a radiotherapy treatment room used for IMRT treatments.
Iranian Journal of Medical Physics
Volume 20, Issue 5
September and October 2023
Pages 305-311

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 26 July 2022
  • Revise Date: 21 October 2022
  • Accept Date: 31 October 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics